Search
New Buffalo, Berrien County, Michigan
23 restaurants with a New Buffalo address, scored out of 100. Updated October 2026.
As of October 2026, the highest-scoring restaurant in New Buffalo, MI on TownAnswer is PostBoy, with a score of 76 out of 100 (4.8 stars from 1,533 Google reviews). Next are Terrace Room (75) and Hummingbird Lounge (74). We scored 23 restaurants with a New Buffalo address. If review count matters most, The Stray Dog Bar & Grill has the most Google reviews (7,401). For the highest star rating with 25 or more reviews, see Papa's Pizza & BBQ - New Buffalo (5.0 stars).
Our October 2026 pull of Google Maps found 23 restaurants with a New Buffalo mailing address. 23 list a website, 23 have claimed their Google listing and 13 take online bookings.
None belongs to a business with three or more Michigan locations in our data.
Every business is scored by the same rules. A business cannot pay for a higher place.
The most-reviewed restaurant in New Buffalo is The Stray Dog Bar & Grill with 7,401 Google reviews. The median rating among scored listings is 4.5 stars.
Highest score first. Tap a name for its website, or Score details for the full breakdown.
The 100-point TownAnswer score. Every restaurant here is checked on the same 5 parts: reputation (26 points), review volume (18), focus (14), profile (22) and verified owner (20). Nobody pays to rank. How we rank
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google1,533 reviews
PostBoy is at 207 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 0.4 miles north of central New Buffalo. Its Google category is "Restaurant". Its 4.8 stars rest on 1,533 reviews, which our method reads as 4.80 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google526 reviews
You will find Terrace Room at 111 W Water St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.4 miles northwest of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Italian restaurant", with Cocktail bar, Fine dining restaurant, Restaurant as extra categories. Its 4.7 stars rest on 526 reviews, which our method reads as 4.69 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google356 reviews
Hummingbird Lounge lists its address as 9 S Barton St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Google files it under "New American restaurant" and also Cocktail bar, Event venue. After we adjust for review count, its 4.7 stars count as 4.69.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google2,054 reviews
Brewster's New Buffalo lists its address as 11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Its Google category is "Italian restaurant", with Bistro, Caterer, Pizza restaurant as extra categories. Its 4.6 stars rest on 2,054 reviews, which our method reads as 4.60 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google1,263 reviews
Rios Mexican Grill lists its address as 603 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.5 miles northeast of the New Buffalo city center. Google files it under "Mexican restaurant" and also Fast food restaurant, Restaurant. Its 4.6 stars rest on 1,263 reviews, which our method reads as 4.60 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google822 reviews
You will find Song Asian Cuisine at 301 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Its Google category is "Asian fusion restaurant", with Asian restaurant, Sushi restaurant as extra categories. Its 4.6 stars rest on 822 reviews, which our method reads as 4.60 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google757 reviews
Bentwood Tavern lists its address as 600 W Water St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.6 miles west of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Restaurant", with American restaurant, Bar, Fine dining restaurant as extra categories. Its 4.5 stars rest on 757 reviews, which our method reads as 4.50 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google722 reviews
Skip's Restaurant and Catering is at 16710 Lakeshore Rd, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 2.6 miles northeast of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Traditional American restaurant", with Restaurant, Steak house as extra categories. Its 4.6 stars rest on 722 reviews, which our method reads as 4.60 after the review-count adjustment.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google105 reviews
Angela’s Provisions is at 225 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 0.4 miles northwest of central New Buffalo. Google files it under "American restaurant". After we adjust for review count, its 4.9 stars count as 4.84.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google7,401 reviews
You will find The Stray Dog Bar & Grill at 245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.4 miles north of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Bar & grill", with Grill, Bar, Hamburger restaurant as extra categories. After we adjust for review count, its 4.5 stars count as 4.50.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google1,485 reviews
Casey's New Buffalo lists its address as 136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.3 miles northwest of the New Buffalo city center. Google files it under "Bar & grill" and also American restaurant, Bar, Irish restaurant. After we adjust for review count, its 4.3 stars count as 4.30.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google2,605 reviews
You will find Beer Church Brewing Co. at 24 S Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Its Google category is "Brewery", with Bar, Beer garden, Beer hall as extra categories. After we adjust for review count, its 4.5 stars count as 4.50.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google473 reviews
David's Delicatessen & Coffee lists its address as 30 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Google files it under "Cafe" and also Breakfast restaurant, Coffee shop, Sandwich shop. Its 4.7 stars rest on 473 reviews, which our method reads as 4.69 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google1,537 reviews
Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo lists its address as 134 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Its Google category is "Pizza restaurant". After we adjust for review count, its 4.2 stars count as 4.20.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google276 reviews
Copper Rock Steakhouse New Buffalo is at 11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 1.9 miles east of central New Buffalo. Its Google category is "Restaurant", with Steak house as extra categories. After we adjust for review count, its 4.3 stars count as 4.31.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find Tacos Los de Catemaco at 800 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.5 miles west of the New Buffalo city center. Google files it under "Fast food restaurant" and also Mexican restaurant, Taco restaurant. Its 4.7 stars rest on 90 reviews, which our method reads as 4.66 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google5,147 reviews
You will find Redamak's at 616 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.5 miles northeast of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Hamburger restaurant", with Family restaurant as extra categories. Its 4.3 stars rest on 5,147 reviews, which our method reads as 4.30 after the review-count adjustment.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google655 reviews
You will find Jackie's Cafe at 801 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.5 miles west of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Brunch restaurant", with Breakfast restaurant, Diner as extra categories. Its 4.3 stars rest on 655 reviews, which our method reads as 4.30 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google
You will find Papa's Pizza & BBQ - New Buffalo at 11541 O'Brien Ct unit d, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 1.5 miles south of central New Buffalo. Google files it under "Pizza restaurant". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.79.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursBooks onlineClaimed on Google570 reviews
You will find Sonny D's Bar & Grill at 1 N Whittaker St # A, New Buffalo, MI 49117. Google files it under "Restaurant" and also American restaurant, Bar & grill. After we adjust for review count, its 4.0 stars count as 4.01.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google566 reviews
Al Fuego Grill & Bar is at 18529 Harbor Country Dr, New Buffalo, MI 49117. That is 0.6 miles southeast of the New Buffalo city center. Its Google category is "Breakfast restaurant", with American restaurant, Bar & grill, Lunch restaurant as extra categories. After we adjust for review count, its 4.3 stars count as 4.30.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google276 reviews
Timbers Fast Food & Deli New Buffalo is at 11111 Wilson Rd, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 1.8 miles east of central New Buffalo. Google files it under "Restaurant". Its 4.0 stars rest on 276 reviews, which our method reads as 4.02 after the review-count adjustment.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
The Grille at The Woodlands lists its address as 12578 Wilson Rd Suite 2, New Buffalo, MI 49117. It sits about 1.7 miles southwest of central New Buffalo. Its Google category is "Bar & grill". Its 4.1 stars rest on 23 reviews, which our method reads as 4.22 after the review-count adjustment.
| # | Business | Score | Grade | Rating | Reviews | Street |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PostBoy | 76 | B+ | 4.8 | 1,533 | 207 N Whittaker St |
| 2 | Terrace Room | 75 | B+ | 4.7 | 526 | 111 W Water St |
| 3 | Hummingbird Lounge | 74 | B | 4.7 | 356 | 9 S Barton St |
| 4 | Brewster's New Buffalo | 73 | B | 4.6 | 2,054 | 11 W Merchant St |
| 5 | Rios Mexican Grill | 73 | B | 4.6 | 1,263 | 603 E Buffalo St |
| 6 | Song Asian Cuisine | 73 | B | 4.6 | 822 | 301 W Buffalo St |
| 7 | Bentwood Tavern | 71 | B | 4.5 | 757 | 600 W Water St |
| 8 | Skip's Restaurant and Catering | 70 | B | 4.6 | 722 | 16710 Lakeshore Rd |
| 9 | Angela’s Provisions | 70 | B | 4.9 | 105 | 225 N Whittaker St |
| 10 | The Stray Dog Bar & Grill | 68 | B- | 4.5 | 7,401 | 245 N Whittaker St |
| 11 | Casey's New Buffalo | 68 | B- | 4.3 | 1,485 | 136 N Whittaker St |
| 12 | Beer Church Brewing Co. | 67 | B- | 4.5 | 2,605 | 24 S Whittaker St |
| 13 | David's Delicatessen & Coffee | 67 | B- | 4.7 | 473 | 30 N Whittaker St |
| 14 | Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo | 66 | B- | 4.2 | 1,537 | 134 E Buffalo St |
| 15 | Copper Rock Steakhouse New Buffalo | 66 | B- | 4.3 | 276 | 11111 Wilson Rd |
| 16 | Tacos Los de Catemaco | 66 | B- | 4.7 | 90 | 800 W Buffalo St |
| 17 | Redamak's | 65 | B- | 4.3 | 5,147 | 616 E Buffalo St |
| 18 | Jackie's Cafe | 65 | B- | 4.3 | 655 | 801 W Buffalo St |
| 19 | Papa's Pizza & BBQ - New Buffalo | 64 | C+ | 5.0 | 28 | 11541 O'Brien Ct unit d |
| 20 | Sonny D's Bar & Grill | 63 | C+ | 4.0 | 570 | 1 N Whittaker St # A |
| 21 | Al Fuego Grill & Bar | 61 | C+ | 4.3 | 566 | 18529 Harbor Country Dr |
| 22 | Timbers Fast Food & Deli New Buffalo | 58 | C | 4.0 | 276 | 11111 Wilson Rd |
| 23 | The Grille at The Woodlands | 55 | C | 4.1 | 23 | 12578 Wilson Rd Suite 2 |
New Buffalo has 1,338 residents on 2.5 square miles of land, about 542 people per square mile (ACS 2024 5-year estimates, Census Gazetteer).
The median household income is $64,702 and the median age is 54.5. These figures describe the town. They do not show who visits any business on this page.
Our October 2026 data has 23 restaurants with a New Buffalo mailing address: 171.9 per 10,000 residents. A mailing city can differ from the city limits, so treat the ratio as a guide.
Call ahead about allergies. Ask how the kitchen keeps an allergen apart, not only whether a dish contains it.
For a group, ask about a set menu, a private room and the deposit rule.
Kitchen hours and bar hours often differ. Check the kitchen hours if you plan a late dinner.
County health departments inspect restaurants in Michigan. You can ask the county for the latest inspection report.
Chains are scored by the same rules as independent restaurants. Each location is scored on its own reviews.
| City | Distance | Restaurants | Top score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Union Pier | 3.7 mi northeast | 3 | 71 |
| Three Oaks | 6.6 mi east | 7 | 73 |
| Harbert | 8.2 mi northeast | 1 | 71 |
| Sawyer | 9.8 mi northeast | 5 | 72 |
| New Troy | 12.1 mi northeast | 1 | 63 |
| Bridgman | 13.4 mi northeast | 13 | 75 |
| Baroda | 17.3 mi northeast | 3 | 66 |
| Stevensville | 19.0 mi northeast | 7 | 73 |
Personal Injury Attorneys 1Plumbers 3Roofers 1HVAC Companies 3Electricians 1Dentists 1Pilates and Fitness Studios 7Photographers 1Coffee Cart Vendors and Mobile Coffee Bars 4Cafés and Coffee Shops 7Real Estate Brokerages 48Dance Studios 1Everything in New BuffaloRestaurants in Berrien County
Our October 2026 data lists 23 restaurants with a New Buffalo mailing address. 23 have a Google rating and are scored. A business can be missing, so treat the count as a floor.
PostBoy has the highest TownAnswer score in New Buffalo: 76 out of 100, from 4.8 stars and 1,533 Google reviews. Scores change when listings change.
Reputation (26 points) is the Google rating adjusted for how many reviews it rests on. Review volume adds up to 18, how closely the business matches the trade up to 14, profile facts such as website, phone, hours, photos and a claimed listing up to 22, and a profile the owner verified with TownAnswer adds 20.
No. Every business is scored by the same rules, and no payment changes a score or a place on a list.
Nearby city pages: Union Pier (3.7 miles), Three Oaks (6.6 miles), Harbert (8.2 miles), Sawyer (9.8 miles).
Do they take reservations, and how far ahead? Can the kitchen handle your allergy or diet? Is there parking, and is the room accessible?
New Buffalo is in Berrien County. See every restaurant in the county on the Berrien County page.
We refresh the data from Google Maps and change the date on the page only when the data changes. This version uses data read in October 2026.
TownAnswer ranks local businesses by one published method. Businesses cannot pay to change their rank. Ratings and review counts come from Google Maps, read in October 2026. Details change, so confirm hours, prices and licences with each business. How we rank.
