Search
Gaylord, Otsego County, Michigan
39 real estate brokerages with a Gaylord address, scored out of 100. Updated October 2026.
As of October 2026, the highest-scoring real estate brokerage in Gaylord, MI on TownAnswer is EverGreen Home Realty, with a score of 65 out of 100 (5.0 stars from 16 Google reviews). Next are Smith Realty Group (64) and Sold On Michigan Team - Northern Michigan Real Estate (63). We scored 28 real estate brokerages with a Gaylord address and list 11 more with no Google rating yet. If review count matters most, Smith Realty Group has the most Google reviews (77).
Our October 2026 pull of Google Maps found 39 real estate brokerages with a Gaylord mailing address. 32 list a website, 29 have claimed their Google listing and 0 take online bookings.
2 belong to a business with three or more Michigan locations in our data. The other 37 have one or two.
Every business is scored by the same rules. A business cannot pay for a higher place.
The most-reviewed real estate brokerage in Gaylord is Smith Realty Group with 77 Google reviews. The median rating among scored listings is 5.0 stars.
Highest score first. Tap a name for its website, or Score details for the full breakdown.
The 100-point TownAnswer score. Every real estate brokerage here is checked on the same 5 parts: reputation (26 points), review volume (18), focus (14), profile (22) and verified owner (20). Nobody pays to rank. How we rank
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find EverGreen Home Realty at 118 E Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.7 miles northeast of central Gaylord. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". Its 5.0 stars rest on 16 reviews, which our method reads as 4.86 after the review-count adjustment.
Claimed on Google
Smith Realty Group lists its address as 1349 S Otsego Ave Ste 9, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.5 miles southeast of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agency". Its 4.5 stars rest on 77 reviews, which our method reads as 4.53 after the review-count adjustment.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
Sold On Michigan Team - Northern Michigan Real Estate is at 1349 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.5 miles southeast of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agent". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.83.
Open after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find Alpine Realty Group Gaylord at 845 S Otsego Ave #2, Gaylord, MI 49735. Google files it under "Real estate agency" and also Real estate agent. After we adjust for review count, its 4.7 stars count as 4.70.
Open 24 hoursWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
Troy Gahm, Real Estate Agent with Smith Realty Group is at 1349 S Otsego Ave Ste 9, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.5 miles southeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agent". Its 5.0 stars rest on 7 reviews, which our method reads as 4.80 after the review-count adjustment.
Opens before 7 AMOpen after 8 PMWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
Team Sheri lists its address as 217 N Court Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.8 miles north of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.79.
Weekend hours
Lake Arrowhead campgrounds lists its address as 7065 Arrowroot Trail, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 7.9 miles southwest of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 4.9 stars count as 4.84. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
TheTEAM Real Estate Group lists its address as 2680 M-32, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 2.5 miles west of central Gaylord. Google files it under "Real estate agency" and also Commercial real estate agency, Consultant, Industrial real estate agency. Its 4.5 stars rest on 16 reviews, which our method reads as 4.60 after the review-count adjustment.
Claimed on Google
You will find Up North Realty at 1624 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.8 miles south of central Gaylord. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". Its 4.5 stars rest on 10 reviews, which our method reads as 4.63 after the review-count adjustment.
Claimed on Google
Team Boyden - Realtors Who Care is at 110 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.7 miles northeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agent", with Real estate consultant as extra categories. Its 5.0 stars rest on 9 reviews, which our method reads as 4.82 after the review-count adjustment.
Claimed on Google
You will find Real Estate One Gaylord at 110 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.7 miles northeast of central Gaylord. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 4.7 stars count as 4.70.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find REALTA | CHESLEY REALTORS® at 685 M-32 Suite 305, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 1.2 miles northeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agency", with Real estate agent as extra categories. After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.79.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
S.C. Derby Real Estate is at 100 W 1st St #0452, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.6 miles northeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agent". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.79.
Claimed on Google
You will find Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Michigan Real Estate at 100 W 1st St, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.6 miles northeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agency", with Commercial real estate agency, Real estate agent, Real estate consultant as extra categories. Its 4.4 stars rest on 22 reviews, which our method reads as 4.53 after the review-count adjustment. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Michigan Real Estate has 35 locations in our Michigan data. Each location is scored on its own reviews.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find Anna Tomaski REALTOR at 700 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.6 miles north of central Gaylord. Its Google category is "Real estate agent". Its 5.0 stars rest on 5 reviews, which our method reads as 4.78 after the review-count adjustment.
Water Wonderland Board-Realtors lists its address as 122 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.6 miles north of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". Its 4.9 stars rest on 8 reviews, which our method reads as 4.78 after the review-count adjustment. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
You will find Donna Stubenvoll Realtor at 110 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.7 miles northeast of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agency" and also Commercial real estate agency. Its 5.0 stars rest on 2 reviews, which our method reads as 4.74 after the review-count adjustment.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
Jennifer Dishaw Michigan Real Estate is at 100 W 1st St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.6 miles northeast of central Gaylord. Google files it under "Real estate agent". Its 5.0 stars rest on 2 reviews, which our method reads as 4.74 after the review-count adjustment.
Claimed on Google
Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors lists its address as 700 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.6 miles north of central Gaylord. Google files it under "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 4.1 stars count as 4.32. Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors has 13 locations in our Michigan data. Each location is scored on its own reviews.
Open 24 hoursWeekend hoursClaimed on Google
Daphne Cousineau Real Estate is at 2680 M-32, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 2.4 miles west of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agency" and also Commercial real estate agency, Real estate agent, Real estate consultant. After we adjust for review count, its 4.2 stars count as 4.58.
★ 5.0 6 Google reviews
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
Lesa Jarski, Associate Broker, Smith Realty Group is at 1349 S Otsego Ave Ste 9, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.5 miles southeast of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agent". Its 5.0 stars rest on 6 reviews, which our method reads as 4.79 after the review-count adjustment.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
Catherine Callahan Realtor - Alpine Realty Group is at 845 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.73.
Weekend hoursClaimed on Google
Jamy Warner Realtor® is at 700 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.6 miles north of central Gaylord. Google files it under "Real estate agent". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.73.
Claimed on Google
You will find Katie Smith, Realtor at 100 W 1st St, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.6 miles northeast of central Gaylord. Google files it under "Real estate agent". Its 5.0 stars rest on 2 reviews, which our method reads as 4.74 after the review-count adjustment.
★ 5.0 2 Google reviews
Weekend hours
KDR - Keith Dressel Realty is at 1738 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. It sits about 0.9 miles south of central Gaylord. Its Google category is "Real estate consultant", with Commercial real estate agency, Real estate agency, Real estate rental agency as extra categories. Its 5.0 stars rest on 2 reviews, which our method reads as 4.74 after the review-count adjustment. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
Cindy Clark Realtor lists its address as 700 W Main St, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 0.6 miles north of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agent". After we adjust for review count, its 5.0 stars count as 4.73. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
Koske Realty Co lists its address as 2192 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 1.3 miles south of the Gaylord city center. Google files it under "Real estate agency". After we adjust for review count, its 3.7 stars count as 4.33. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
Weekend hours
Blaker Realty is at 3511 Old US Hwy 27 S S, Gaylord, MI 49735. That is 2.7 miles south of the Gaylord city center. Its Google category is "Real estate agency". Its 3.2 stars rest on 27 reviews, which our method reads as 3.74 after the review-count adjustment. The owner has not claimed the Google listing.
These businesses have a Gaylord address but no Google rating, so they carry no score.
| Business | Street | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| Alpine Realty - Team4Sold | 400 W Main St | (989) 619-2476 |
| Amy Fiser | REALTOR | 403 W Main St Ste A | (989) 350-5154 |
| Catt's Realty | 829 W Main St Ste C | (989) 732-9722 |
| Celeste Lovely Feole - Real Estate Agent | 845 S Otsego Ave 2 Suite C | (989) 858-5494 |
| Connie Madej Real Estate Agent | 2680 M32W | (989) 370-1096 |
| Hannah Techel Realtor | 2680 M-32 | (989) 858-0464 |
| Otsego County Realty (in Gaylord Michigan) | 1678 Ashley Ln | (989) 350-7997 |
| Otsego Property Services | 320 S Center Ave | (989) 731-4226 |
| RE/MAX Up North : Bob Hunley | 1624 S Otsego Ave | (989) 710-2067 |
| Samantha VanSickle, Realtor | 700 W Main St | (989) 858-3953 |
| Tyrek Jones REALTOR® | 700 W Main St | (443) 415-8010 |
Gaylord has 4,357 residents and 2,306 households (ACS 2024 5-year estimates for Gaylord city). 44.9 percent of its homes were built before 1980, and the median home was built in 1,983.
30.9 percent of homes are owner-occupied. The median home value is $192,800. Older housing stock tends to need more plumbing, roofing, electrical and water damage work, so these figures help explain local demand. They do not measure it.
Our October 2026 data has 39 real estate brokerages with a Gaylord mailing address: 89.5 per 10,000 residents. A mailing city can differ from the city limits, so treat the ratio as a guide.
Real estate agents and brokers in Michigan hold a licence from LARA. You can check a name on LARA Verify a License before you sign.
Commission is negotiable. Ask what the brokerage charges, who pays it, and what you get for it: pricing advice, marketing, showings, negotiation and help through closing.
After the National Association of Realtors settlement took effect in August 2024, buyers working with a Realtor sign a written agreement before touring homes. Read the pay terms and the length of the agreement.
Ask how many homes the agent sold in your city or school district in the last year, and at what price compared with the list price.
Many agents work in teams. Ask who answers your calls and who attends showings and inspections.
| City | Distance | Real Estate Brokerages | Top score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bagley Township | 2.9 mi southeast | 1 | 52 |
| Livingston Township | 3.9 mi north | 1 | 68 |
| Elmira | 7.0 mi northwest | 2 | n/a |
| Corwith Township | 10.8 mi northeast | 1 | 61 |
| Charlton Township | 12.5 mi east | 2 | 56 |
| Boyne Falls | 15.3 mi northwest | 2 | 54 |
| Frederic | 18.7 mi south | 1 | 63 |
| Mancelona | 20.3 mi southwest | 5 | 52 |
Personal Injury Attorneys 5Water Damage Restoration Companies 3Mold Remediation Companies 2Plumbers 14Roofers 6HVAC Companies 12Electricians 9Dentists 22Med Spas 6Pilates and Fitness Studios 7Photographers 12Coffee Cart Vendors and Mobile Coffee Bars 5Cafés and Coffee Shops 14Restaurants 43Dance Studios 3Everything in GaylordReal Estate Brokerages in Otsego County
Our October 2026 data lists 39 real estate brokerages with a Gaylord mailing address. 28 have a Google rating and are scored. A business can be missing, so treat the count as a floor.
EverGreen Home Realty has the highest TownAnswer score in Gaylord: 65 out of 100, from 5.0 stars and 16 Google reviews. Scores change when listings change.
Reputation (26 points) is the Google rating adjusted for how many reviews it rests on. Review volume adds up to 18, how closely the business matches the trade up to 14, profile facts such as website, phone, hours, photos and a claimed listing up to 22, and a profile the owner verified with TownAnswer adds 20.
No. Every business is scored by the same rules, and no payment changes a score or a place on a list.
Nearby city pages: Bagley Township (2.9 miles), Livingston Township (3.9 miles), Elmira (7.0 miles), Corwith Township (10.8 miles).
Is the agent licensed in Michigan? Check the name on LARA Verify a License. What does the brokerage charge, and who pays it? Commission is negotiable. Since August 2024, buyers sign a written agreement with their agent before touring. Read what it says about pay and length.
Gaylord is in Otsego County. See every real estate brokerage in the county on the Otsego County page.
We refresh the data from Google Maps and change the date on the page only when the data changes. This version uses data read in October 2026.
TownAnswer ranks local businesses by one published method. Businesses cannot pay to change their rank. Ratings and review counts come from Google Maps, read in October 2026. Details change, so confirm hours, prices and licences with each business. How we rank.
